What Went Wrong with ‘chemistry’ by Kelly Clarkson — And Why It Still Deserves to Be Heard
When Kelly Clarkson released Chemistry in June 2023, many expected a powerful return—an album exploring love, heartbreak, and the journey of healing following her public divorce. With a legacy of chart-topping hits and Grammy-winning albums, Clarkson is no stranger to making waves in the industry. However, Chemistry struggled to achieve the commercial impact of her previous works, debuting at No. 6 on the Billboard 200 with an initial 43,000 units sold. While respectable, these numbers fell short of expectations for one of pop music’s most recognizable voices, especially when compared to Clarkson’s earlier successes like Breakaway, Stronger, and Piece by Piece, which each earned significant accolades and higher initial sales.
One factor impacting the album’s reception was its choice of lead singles. Clarkson chose two mid-tempo ballads, “mine” and “me,” to introduce Chemistry. While both tracks were emotionally resonant and reflective of the album’s thematic content, they didn’t quite capture its full musical range. The introspective nature of these songs may have undersold the dynamic diversity within Chemistry, particularly its upbeat tracks like “favorite kind of high,” or “rock hudson.” Releasing a more energetic lead single could have set a different tone, highlighting Clarkson’s versatility and encouraging broader radio play. Fans familiar with Clarkson’s previous singles, often filled with infectious energy and undeniable hooks, might have expected something with a bit more punch to launch the album.
Timing also played a role in Chemistry‘s challenges. Its release came during the Hollywood writer’s strike, which limited promotional options on late-night shows and other media outlets. This created a unique obstacle, especially as the entertainment industry navigated new promotional landscapes without traditional media support.
Additionally, Clarkson’s exclusive Birthday at the Belasco concert, where she performed Chemistry tracks live, created excitement among her fanbase. However, only select clips from this intimate show were released, with no full concert recording made publicly available. Releasing a full version of Birthday at the Belasco could have boosted Chemistry‘s visibility and given fans a deeper connection to the new music through a live experience. A professionally released recording of the event would have provided a unique promotional asset and drawn in more listeners by capturing the raw emotion and vocal prowess Clarkson brings to her live performances.
Though the album was expertly produced by names like Aaron Chafin and mixed by Mark Needham, Chemistry faced a perfect storm of promotional limitations and questionable single choices that prevented it from reaching its full potential. While the album’s introspective journey through heartbreak and healing is undeniably poignant, a more strategic approach might have allowed Chemistry to resonate more broadly with audiences and achieve greater commercial success.
Despite its hurdles, Chemistry went on to earn a Grammy nomination, a testament to the quality and emotional depth of the project. Many critics and fans have argued that this is Clarkson’s most personal and best work yet, showcasing her ability to translate raw emotion into music that touches the soul. Though commercial success didn’t fully reflect the album’s brilliance, it remains an essential listen, deserving of recognition and appreciation for its artistry and honesty. Chemistry is not just an album—it’s a story that deserves to be heard.
Stay tuned to MusicOnTheRox.com for all your music news and reviews.