Most bands leave their back catalog alone. RISE didn’t. The Liverpool four-piece, Sam Kinley on bass and vocals under the name stayMellow, Paul Kinley on keyboards and backing vocals, Alex Mahoney on drums, and Brian Petch on guitar, first released “Hard To Leave You” in 2024 on their EP “Memories and Possibilities,” and then spent a while quietly dissatisfied with it. Not with the song, which they still believed in, but with the recording, which never managed to bottle whatever happens when they play the thing in front of an audience.
So they went back and did it again.
Hard To Leave You
This new version carries the Barbarian mix tag, though calling it a remix undersells what actually happened. It’s closer to an admission that the first attempt sold the song short. Cut at Whitewood Studios in Liverpool, with Rob Whiteley producing alongside Paul Kinley, who also wrote it, the rebuild mostly stops the band apologizing for how loud they are. Whiteley is a long-standing choice rather than a new hire, and the reason seems to be that he can get a band this dense onto a recording without flattening any of it.
Petch’s guitar sits considerably higher this time, sharper and more insistent than before, but the synth layers that have always separated RISE from a straight-ahead rock band are still audible underneath rather than buried by it. That balance is the whole trick, and plenty of bands lose it the moment they decide to go heavier. RISE have put years and a great many stages into sharpening that particular combination, which is why they tend to be identifiable within a couple of bars.
stayMellow is where the track earns its keep. He isn’t performing heartbreak exactly, which would be the easier assignment. He’s performing indecision, and there’s real tension held in the delivery, enough that you believe the person singing genuinely hasn’t worked out what he’s going to do yet.
The writing never arrives at a verdict either. It isn’t a kiss-off and it isn’t a plea to stay, it occupies the messier ground where someone understands a relationship is probably finished and still can’t make himself move. A lot of breakup songs skip that part, because certainty is easier to write and easier to sing. This one parks itself there deliberately, which is exactly why it holds up past a first listen. Anyone who gravitates toward the more theatrical end of alt-rock, Panic! At The Disco and that lineage, will find plenty to grab onto.
Final Thoughts
Going back to a song you’ve already put out takes a certain amount of nerve, and this one justifies it. What exists now sounds a lot more like whatever the band was hearing in their heads the first time around.
You can find RISE on Spotify, on Instagram, on YouTube, on Apple Music, and via their Linktree. Stay tuned to MusicOnTheRox.com for all your music news and reviews.
